Prefer to watch? Here’s the summary:
November 16, 2026 | Portfolio Lens Research
The American homeowner has rediscovered thrift, a virtue long admired, but rarely practiced. Faucets get fixed and fences get painted, but the new kitchen, the finished basement or the addition over the garage has been deferred until mortgage rates become reasonable or the house is sold, whichever never comes first. Home Depot’s finance chief, Richard McPhail, told investors in August there is “just no sign of an inflection point” in housing turnover. Lowe’s chief executive, Marvin Ellison, said his customers are “prioritizing where and when they invest in their homes,” which is the polite way of saying they are not.
So as the two great home improvement chains enter their third quarter, sales may stay modest. Home Depot reports on Tuesday, November 17 and Lowe’s on Wednesday, both before the market opens. The question is whether all this patience is a pause or a habit and whether either company’s forecasts already assume the answer.
How we keep score. Before a company reports, we publish lines: the result that would mark a strong quarter and the one that would mark a weak one. A result at or beyond the strong line earns a Bull grade; at or beyond the weak line, Bear; everything between is Neutral. For costs and spending, lower is better. After the report we grade against the company’s own earnings release and SEC filings, not analyst estimates, and we don’t move the lines. The purpose of scorecards is not to prove that we can see the future. It is to prevent ourselves from rewriting the past.
Our lines (written November 8, 2026, before either company reports)
Home Depot (reports Tuesday, November 17, before the open; call at 9:00 a.m. ET)
Fiscal 2026. All four lines grade the full year, on the figures Home Depot gives on Tuesday; repeating today’s forecasts grades Neutral.
Bull Case
Full-year sales growth: At or above 4.5% (current forecast 2.5–4.5%).
Full-year operating margin: At or above 12.6% (current forecast 12.4–12.6%).
Full-year gross margin: At or above 33.1% (current forecast about 33.1%).
Full-year organic sales growth at SRS, its business serving professional roofers, landscapers and pool builders: At or above 6%.
Bear Case
Full-year sales growth: At or below 2.5%.
Full-year operating margin: At or below 12.4%.
Full-year gross margin: At or below 33.1%.
SRS organic sales growth: At or below 4%.
A gross-margin forecast of about 33.1% grades Neutral, as does SRS growth between 4% and 6%, where management’s “mid-single digits” sits now.
Why This Release Matters
In the quarter that ended in August, sales rose 5.7% to $47.9 billion, much of it from acquisitions, chiefly GMS. Comparable sales rose just 1.7%: customers made 1.0% fewer transactions and spent 2.8% more on each. Big-ticket transactions over $1,000 grew 2.4%, yet management said “larger discretionary projects remain under pressure.” Professional contractors outspent do-it-yourselfers, which is what happens when the people who can still afford a renovation hire someone else to do it.
Two things flattered that quarter and now fade. GMS joined in September 2025, so it stops adding growth. And about $730 million of tariff refunds helped the margin; management said that benefit is offset across the second and third quarters. Home Depot reaffirmed its full-year forecast in August and McPhail said the third quarter started “really consistent with the demand we saw in the second quarter.” The lines ask whether reaffirmation survives another season of consistency.
Lowe’s (reports Wednesday, November 18, before the open; call at 9:00 a.m. ET)
Third quarter of fiscal 2026, plus what Lowe’s says about the full year.
Bull Case
Third-quarter sales: At or above $21.0B.
Third-quarter diluted EPS (excluding one-time items): At or above $2.80.
Full-year EPS forecast (excluding one-time items): raised above about $12.25, or kept there with upward commentary.
Bear Case
Third-quarter sales: At or below $20.5B.
Third-quarter diluted EPS (excluding one-time items): At or below $2.60.
Full-year EPS forecast: lowered below about $12.25.
Reaffirming the forecast at about $12.25 grades Neutral. Lowe’s guided third-quarter adjusted EPS about 7% below last year’s $3.06, so meeting its own forecast would clear our Bull line and the acquisitions alone add more than a billion dollars to the quarter’s sales.
Why This Release Matters
Lowe’s sales rose 8.3% to $26.0 billion in the quarter that ended in July, almost entirely because it bought FBM and ADG, two suppliers to professional builders. Comparable sales rose 0.2% and July fell 1.2%. Transactions dropped 2.1% and gross margin slipped 77 basis points. Then came the less cheerful part: Lowe’s moved its full-year forecast to the bottom of its range, about $92 billion of sales and $12.25 of adjusted EPS.
Its executives were candid about the customer. Joe McFarland, who runs the stores, said contractors see “a homeowner that is more cautious about their spending,” which leads “to consistently smaller projects.” Lowe’s has lowered its ambitions once. Wednesday will show whether a smaller ambition was the right size or merely the first of several fittings.
Thresholds first. Grades later. Misses included.
Sources: Home Depot Q2 fiscal 2026 earnings release (8-K Ex. 99.1) · Home Depot Q2 10-Q · Home Depot Q2 call transcript · Lowe’s Q2 2026 earnings release (8-K Ex. 99.1) · Lowe’s Q2 10-Q · Lowe’s Q2 call transcript. Report dates from each company’s announcement. As of November 14, 2026.
Not investment advice. Research for informational purposes only. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Past performance does not indicate future results.

