Prefer to watch? Here’s the summary:
November 17, 2026 | Portfolio Lens Research
Walmart and Target sell nearly everything to nearly everyone, which makes them the closest thing the country has to a household budget with a ticker symbol. Both arrive at their third quarters in an unusually good humor and for an unusual reason: the government is returning tariffs it should not have collected. Walmart received about $2.9 billion of refunds last quarter and Target $994 million and both promptly raised their forecasts. Very rarely do companies thank Washington for their profits rather than blaming it for their absence.
Refunds, however, are not customers. Walmart’s finance chief, John David Rainey, noticed shoppers were “making trade-offs” in June and its new chief executive, John Furner, said they are “still feeling some pressure.” Target’s new chief executive, Michael Fiddelke, conceded that “flattish growth in apparel and home isn’t what we strive for over time.” Target reports on Wednesday, November 18 and Walmart on Thursday, November 19, both before the market opens. The question for both of them is whether shoppers are still buying what they want or only what they need.
How we keep score. Before a company reports, we publish our lines: the results that would mark a strong quarter and the ones that would mark a weak one. A result at or above the strong line earns a Bull grade; at or below the weak line is a Bear; everything between is Neutral. After the company files we grade ourselves against the company’s own earnings release and SEC filings, not analyst estimates. And we don’t move the lines. The purpose of scorecards is not to prove that we can see the future. It is to prevent ourselves from rewriting the past.
Our lines (written November 8, 2026, before either company reports)
Target (reports Wednesday, November 18, before the open; call at 8:00 a.m. ET)
Fiscal 2026. One line, graded on the full-year forecast Target gives on Wednesday.
Bull: full-year EPS (excluding one-time items) at or above $10.90, the top of its current $9.90–10.90 forecast.
Bear: at or below $9.90, the bottom of it.
Everything between, including a repeat of today’s range, grades Neutral.
Why This Release Matters
Target’s comparable sales rose 3.8% in the quarter that ended in August, a welcome change from a 1.9% decline a year earlier and traffic rose 3.6%. Digital sales grew 8.7% and beauty 7.2%. Apparel and home, the categories that once defined the store, were flat. Target executive Cara Sylvester said the company is “not satisfied with the performance in either of those businesses.” Earnings per share doubled to $4.11, but $1.65 of that came from refunds. Target then lifted its full-year forecast to $9.90–10.90 from $7.50–8.50. The line asks whether the new range holds once the refunds are behind it and the remodeled stores have to earn their keep.
Walmart (reports Thursday, November 19, before the open; release at 7:00 a.m. ET, call at 8:00 a.m. ET)
Fiscal third quarter 2027.
Bull Case
Walmart U.S. comparable sales, excluding fuel: At or above 3.5%.
Global e-commerce sales growth: At or above 25%.
Bear Case
Walmart U.S. comparable sales, excluding fuel: At or below 2.6%, last quarter’s rate.
Global e-commerce sales growth: At or below 20%.
Everything between is Neutral.
Why This Release Matters
Walmart’s U.S. comparable sales rose 2.6% in the quarter that ended in July, down from 4.6% a year earlier and slowed by new government drug pricing in its pharmacies. Customers made 1.5% more trips but added only 1.1% to each basket. E-commerce grew 23% worldwide and advertising 38%, which is how a grocer earns a software company’s margins on a few of its dollars. Walmart raised its full-year outlook to $2.80–2.87 of adjusted EPS and used much of the refund money to cut prices, lifting the number of rollbacks from about 7,200 to more than 11,000.
That is the week’s real experiment. If lower prices bring more shoppers, comparable sales should accelerate past last quarter’s 2.6%. If they merely bring the same shoppers paying less, the rollbacks will have been generosity rather than strategy. Rainey warned of “more than $2 billion of incremental cost tied to higher fuel prices in arguably a softer consumer environment.” Thursday will show which kind of environment it was.
Thresholds first. Grades later. Misses included.
Sources: Target Q2 2026 earnings release (8-K Ex. 99) · Target Q2 call transcript · Walmart Q2 fiscal 2027 earnings release · Walmart Q2 call transcript. Report dates from each company’s announcement. As of November 14, 2026.
Not investment advice. Research for informational purposes only. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Past performance does not indicate future results.

